(December 2006) Michael Heyeck was named senior vice president of transmission at American Electric Power Co. Duke Energy announced that Jim Stanley would lead its...
Utility M&A: Buying Time
Slowly and cautiously, utilities are moving back into growth mode.
The air is buzzing with talk of mergers and acquisitions (M&A). It can be heard in the boardroom and on the trading floor. Bankers hear it, and they see their deal backlog beginning to grow. Fund managers hear it, as they hunt for the best buys in the market before strategic investors snatch them up. Financial advisers and lawyers hear it, too; their phones are ringing more than they have in years.
But is it for real? Is the buzz just a lot of talk, signifying nothing more than wishful thinking from Wall Street? Or is a wave of utility M&As truly on the way?
"There was a noticeable increase in comments about M&A in the June earnings conference calls," says Jim Hempstead, vice president and senior analyst with Moody's Investors Service in New York. "The primary rationale behind M&A is to pursue earnings growth through scale and scope, but impediments to that rationale exist."
Utility mergers are complicated, costly and difficult to justify-to ratepayers, shareholders, and regulators alike. Nevertheless, many of the fundamental drivers that favor M&A are moving into place. Debt costs are low; many utilities are in a strong cash position; and investors are beginning to apply pressure as they look for growth opportunities exceeding utilities' low organic growth rates.
These drivers, combined with the prevailing "back-to-basics" mindset among utility investors and regulators, are pushing the industry toward consolidation. Whether and when companies go along with that push depends on their ability to develop a business case that makes sense. And they seem to be in no hurry.
"The industry is in an interesting state of change," says Marc S. Lipschultz, a partner with Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. in New York. "Companies have gone through some wild gyrations over the past five years, and now a lot of people are taking time to assess where to go next."
Economic forces are putting pressure on gas and electric companies to pursue growth again, after about a three-year period of contraction, cleanup, and restructuring.
"Obviously credit quality has stabilized," says Mike Haggarty, vice president and senior credit officer at Moody's. "Liquidity has improved over the past two or three years." This improvement has resulted from companies refinancing debt and liquidating assets-especially unregulated assets.
"The average U.S. electric and gas utility is pretty solid today, with ratings in investment-grade territory," says Peter N. Rigby, a director with Standard & Poor's in New York. "The ones that managed to stay out of merchant power and telecom exploits a few years ago maintain higher ratings. Many are in the A and A+ categories, and are quite strong in many ways."
The key to this recovery has been companies' ability to retire debt and refinance it at lower interest rates. Economic stimulus provided by the Federal Reserve, in the form of rock-bottom interest rates, has given the industry the financial flexibility it needed to survive the disaster of Enron's collapse and everything that followed it.
"Power companies can tip their