The benefits of DR remain difficult to quantify. Building a comprehensive business case requires a shift in how policy makers think about DR in order to understand its real possibilities.
Minnesota has lots of drafts, but no final plan.
So you think your state has been busy? In Minnesota, the 1997 legislative session saw more than a dozen new bills introduced on electric, gas and energy issues.
At the start of the session many expected that electric deregulation would play a major part in the legislative program. However, Gov. Carlson reports now that legislators will defer work on the issue until the 1998 session. Several electric industry deregulation bills were introduced at the end of the session, but when last we checked no hearings had been held.
Electric Retail Choice
Omnibus Energy Bill (Chapter 191) (em
s Requires task force to study deregulation and make recommendations to the Legislature by Jan. 15, 1998. (Only item passed so far on electric deregulation.)
s Utility customers with loads of 2 megawatts per hour or larger will enjoy reduced rates. (State public utilities commission must approve rates.)
s Utility property tax exemption for hydroelectric or hydromechanical power on a federally owned site.
s Calls for study of personal property tax on electric and gas utilities in the state.
s All electric generators must report annually mercury emission levels to the state.
Minnesota Energy Consumers Bill (H.F. 2149/S.F. 1950) (em Residential and small-business customers would get choice of electric suppliers, plus a 7.5-percent rate cut, by Jan. 1, 1999. All customers would have choice by Jan. 1, 2000.
Minnesota Responsible Electric Competition Act (H.F. 2238) (em Would prepare state to comply with a federally mandated deadline for electric retail competition. Would set standards for service reliability, safety, consumer protection and environmental safeguards.
UtiliCorp Model Bill (H.F. 2229) (em Bill sets standards for restructuring state's electric utility industry. Would require unbundling of electric rates as quickly as possible and full customer choice by Dec. 15, 2000.
Minnesota Electric System Public Benefits Protection Act of 1997 (H.F. 2238) (em Bill imposes a wires charge, with proceeds to go to renewable energy sources, universal electric service, affordable electric service, energy conservation and research and development. Requires that by 2009, 10 percent of electricity generated in the state come from renewable energy sources, among other environmental provisions.
Nuclear Waste Fee Escrow Account (Chapter 201) (em Allows Minnesota to take full advantage of any relief granted by the federal courts in pending cases brought by states and utilities over the U.S. Department of Energy's nuclear waste disposal obligations. (Law passed.)
Minnesota Nuclear Responsibility Act of 1997 (S.F. 880/S.F. 843) (em Would have reactivated and reorganized the state's Nuclear Waste Council.
Carbon Taxes (S.F. 110/H.F. 1110/H.F 1190) (em Would have subjected coal, mixed municipal waste and natural gas and liquid fuel to an "emission assessment" based on the fuel's known carbon content.
Utility Personal Property Taxes (H.F. 1298 and H.F. 2235) (em Both would have overhauled utility personal property tax. A study of such taxes was part of the Omnibus Energy Bill.
Wind and Biomass
Certificate of Need Exemptions (Chapter 198) (em Exempts the electric generating plant selected to implement the wind and biomass mandates of the Prairie Island