Some in Congress would link customer choice with a portfolio standard. How would that play in a wholesale power market where gas turbines rule the roost?
By Michael C. Brower and Brian...
limitation would affect the ratepayer, as well as TransConnect LLC, the independent transmission company that would operate within the RTO.
Lincoln Wolverton, consultant to ICNU, calls the agreement a "blanket prohibition against liability." The agreement, Wolverton says, seems to clear RTO West and the utilities of liability in cases of negligence. "The language was too restrictive," he says.
But again, the utilities argue that they are just trying to maintain the status quo. Tariff limitations of liability, they say, have generally shielded utilities from liability to customers for service interruptions, except in cases of willful misconduct or gross negligence, and that's a good thingeven for the end-user, because it keeps rates low. Furthermore, the courts have recognized that "the customers most vulnerable to interruptions are in the best position to protect themselves through back-up generation." In other words, the industrial users for whom ICNU advocates should be somewhat responsible for their own power quality.
According to the utilities, in today's litigious environment, not limiting liability, in fact, could spell disaster: "[G]iven the imagination and resourcefulness of today's litigants and absent tariff protection damages resulting from a single interruption of service event could result in plaintiffs owning the utility or the imposition of astronomical rates to recoup liability payments."
Finally, say the utilities, imposing the bulk of liability on electric providers not only will increase the cost of electric service, but "may well render insurance unavailable at any cost." A Jan. 16 response by ICUN states that RTO West's later filing contains no "substantive changes to the four main documents," including the agreement limiting liability.
Articles found on this page are available to Internet subscribers only. For more information about obtaining a username and password, please call our Customer Service Department at 1-800-368-5001.