Takeaways from Meta-Analysis of Decarbonization Studies

Deck: 

GTI Energy, Evolved Energy Research

Fortnightly Magazine - August 2024

GTI Energy recently released a Meta-Analysis of U.S. Economy-Wide Decarbonization Studies for Net-Zero Energy Systems, referred to as Meta NZ. It's important — as EPRI and GTI Energy created the Low-Carbon Resources Initiative (LCRI) to together address the need to accelerate development and demonstration of low- and zero-carbon energy technologies required for deep decarbonization. 

Meta NZ provides a comparative analysis of five U.S. economy-wide net-zero studies developed by LCRI, Open Energy Outlook, Evolved Energy Research, Princeton University, and Decarb America. It enables like-for-like comparisons among different studies and scenarios.

Public Utilities Fortnightly brought together two experts who worked on Meta NZ to discuss its perspectives and analytical frameworks for offering a comprehensive look at designs for net-zero energy systems. Author and GTI Energy's Derek Wissmiller was joined by Evolved Energy Research's Ryan Jones to review the collaborative effort.

 

PUF's Steve Mitnick: What led GTI Energy to pursue this meta-analysis of the decarbonization studies? Why is it important for you to understand and communicate the net-zero studies?

Derek Wissmiller: What can you learn about U.S. economy-wide, net-zero systems when you look across everything out there on an apples-to-apples basis? That’s what our Meta NZ report sets out to deliver.

Derek Wissmiller: There's a lot of conversation and decision making centered around how to drive economies to net zero. But to have an informed set of conversations and decision-making efforts around the how, you need to have an informed view of the what, which is what net zero might actually look like.

We're a long way from fully transitioning to net zero, which means there's plenty of uncertainty surrounding what net zero is going to look like. GTI Energy set out to lead this Meta-Analysis of U.S. Economy-Wide Decarbonization Studies, which we call Meta NZ, because there's value in trying to map out the range of possibilities.

There's value in doing that through a collaborative effort that encompasses an array of perspectives across multiple independent studies. While there is a wide range of outcomes across these studies, there are some clear commonalities that give a directional sense of where we should be headed to get to net zero.

PUF: What do you mean by meta-analysis?

Ryan Jones: One of the most powerful takeaways from many of these studies is what they agree on over the next decade, because that becomes the playbook to identify no-regret strategies and to chip away at these problems.

Derek Wissmiller: Meta NZ provides a comparative analysis of five U.S. economy-wide net-zero studies developed by the Low-Carbon Resources Initiative, Open Energy Outlook, Evolved Energy Research, Princeton University, and Decarb America. The five studies are about as analytically rigorous as you can get.

In Meta NZ, we pull together the results from these various studies on a like-for-like basis. When you plot different studies on the same axis and in the same units, you can readily see the range of options and possibilities.

You can see some common trends in the data rather than trying to interpret the top-level findings of one study versus another. By putting the results on a common basis, you can make sense of them in an objective way.

PUF: The paths are all over the place. For example, some studies were heavy on nuclear, others with batteries or a lot or a little of gas. You had to work that out.

Derek Wissmiller: That's right. That's because these studies are specifically framed to ask, "What if?" They do this by evaluating a range of different possible net-zero scenarios. 

For example, some scenarios are defined to ask the question, "What happens if you don't allow fossil fuels," or "What if you limit the rate at which wind and solar can be built?" These different scenarios aren't necessarily suggesting what is going to happen or what should happen but help to inform the impact of various factors and constraints. They help us map out the corners and possibilities across a multidimensional set of uncertainties and possibilities.

PUF: What were some insights you took away from the study of studies?

Derek Wissmiller: All these studies and scenarios have some level of optimization, solving for economy-wide, net-zero emissions at the lowest cost. Given this optimization, you might think that the model would pick a single best pathway or technology.

But because of the variety of energy services needed across our economy — vehicles, industry, building, heating, cooling, et cetera — and the various attributes of different energy sources, what comes out of these analyses is a myriad of pathways and solutions. 

We see a diversity of methods for producing both electricity and fuels, and in ways that are increasingly low carbon. Carbon management is deployed in a multitude of ways across energy systems, providing a means for emissions abatement, carbon dioxide removal, or carbon utilization. Efficiency improvements are adopted across the board as a key enabler of emissions reductions. 

These studies give an idea of what net zero might look like, but we need to take them with a dose of humility given how far we are from net zero today. At the same time, there are consistent commonalities in these studies; some things we will do a lot less of in the future, and some things we consistently will do a lot more of. 

These studies provide helpful indicators that can point us in the right direction. But it's also helpful to keep our minds open to the new insights and the disruptive innovations that can happen as we progress to net zero.

PUF: How does that relate to affordability? There's an upward sloping curve as you get closer to one hundred percent.

Derek Wissmiller: Yes, that's right. The cost curve tends to be a bit nonlinear.

One thing that consistently comes out across these studies, is that the costs for getting to net zero increase as more constraints are introduced. Net-zero scenarios that have more constraints on the types of energy sources or technologies that are allowed, end up costing more than scenarios that have fewer constraints.

So, there is value in not constraining ourselves too much right now. We've still got a long way to go to get to net zero, and there is sure to be a lot of learning along the way. There is value in pursuing a variety of solutions as we work to drive down emissions across our economies.

PUF: Ryan, what were your key takeaways from the meta-analysis?

Ryan Jones: Overall, many of these studies find similar pillars that are the core part of decarbonization. One of the key pieces of our findings is that the uncertainty range, while it's large, is expanding out into the future.

One of the most powerful takeaways from many of these studies is what they agree on over the next decade, because that becomes the playbook to identify no-regret strategies and to chip away at these problems. I would rather have a nimble ability to respond to changing conditions on the way to net zero than a perfect blueprint or plan to start out with, because there is no such thing.

The process of doing these net-zero studies is one in which as we move along — this is no different than any other electric utility planning process — an integrated resource plan is updated every couple of years, and you have more information and better insights into the decisions you can make. It makes it a little less daunting to think about it in that context.

PUF: Society presently is a little over twenty percent electric. Where will that go? Were the studies varied?

Ryan Jones: Most studies from that twenty percent today, tend to roughly double the amount of final energy coming from electricity. Electrification is an important lever, even if it's not the whole picture.

If something can be electrified and has big efficiency benefits for doing so, for example, by going from an ICE engine to a battery electric vehicle and then miles per gallon of gas equivalent will quadruple. That's a place where economically, in a net-zero economy, you're going to be pushed to electrify.

Likewise, if you can electrify something and operate it flexibly to take advantage of times when there is variable generation, that's another place where the economics become compelling. The places where neither of those are true or you've got aviation, other places where storing down electricity is a challenge, then it gets more complex.

All this goes back to the cost of different primary energy sources. The truth is renewable electricity is the cheapest form of primary energy that's zero carbon that we know how to make.

That's why all these systems get pushed toward electrification and flexible use of wind and solar.

That would be different if biomass was the cheapest form of zero-carbon electricity, and we didn't have the constraints on land and potential. You could imagine a whole system being very different if the story around primary energy costs was different.

PUF: Why should our readers read this report and what should they expect to see in it?

Derek Wissmiller: Let's say you're interested in getting to net zero. I think a good place to start is by trying to understand what net zero might look like. 

Rather than looking at net zero through the lens of a single group or study, it's helpful to cast an even wider net. What can you learn about U.S. economy-wide, net-zero systems when you look across everything that's out there on an apples-to-apples basis? That's what our Meta NZ report sets out to deliver.

PUF: What should readers expect to see in this report and want to take away from it?

Ryan Jones: One thing to highlight — we've touched on this a little bit — the electric power system is at the hub of so many net-zero activities. We are coming out of a two-decade period in the U.S. where load growth has been relatively slow. While we have had changes on the supply side of the power system, they're nowhere near as dramatic as what has been envisioned in these studies.

The electric power system operators and regulated utilities need to take note of what is in these studies. Because as policymakers try to implement net-zero mandates across the country, the electric power system is going to be thrust into the middle of implementation.

Whether you like it or not, all these pathways involve a lot of change quickly on the electric power system side. There are huge challenges, but also big opportunities that come from a doubling of electricity load.

Derek Wissmiller: To build on Ryan's comments, part of the value of these studies is they look at electrification within the context of the entire economy. They help us to understand what demands might be electrified versus those that may continue to be served with gaseous or liquid fuels. They help us to understand how electric, fuels, and carbon-management systems might interact with one another.

There are many groups thinking about net zero. But they are often looking at net zero through an individual sector, energy carrier, or value chain. 

The benefit of these economy-wide studies is that they put it all together. They allow you to assess what net zero means for the electric and gas sectors, the transportation and liquid fuels sectors, and so on, all within the broader context of an economy-wide energy system.

PUF: What is your take on five years out or fifteen years out to 2050?

Derek Wissmiller: The time element is difficult to assess. There is a lot of uncertainty when trying to forecast the speed with which things are likely to happen.

Irrespective of timing, these studies point to a lot of change on the path to net zero. A lot of new technology and infrastructure needs to be deployed. 

At the same time, a lot of what we use today still has a role in net-zero energy systems. This isn't necessarily at the front of people's minds, but fuel-based systems and the infrastructure that supports them continue to be used in these systems.

For example, take gas-fired power generation. This serves as a backstop for firm and flexible generation in all scenarios, meeting peak demands when wind, solar, storage, and other generation are insufficient.

Hence, gas transport and storage infrastructure are leveraged in support of these net-zero energy systems. This is the benefit of these studies. They look at net-zero energy systems as a system of systems, characterizing the integration and interplay across different sectors, energy carriers, and value chains.

Ryan Jones: One of the paradoxes of some of these pathways is that if we do it right, there are a lot of changes that happen either under the hood or upstream on the industrial energy side. But the end consumer, if you're doing this right, is not noticing a huge change in day-to-day lived experience with the energy system.

The problem here is not using energy, in fact, we probably want to use more energy. Wherever we use more energy, there is a better quality of life. Especially globally, there is a problem of energy poverty, and more is needed. That is the success story to be had.

This is a marathon, not a sprint. It's going to take decades for these changes to be implemented.

The energy system has so much infrastructure tied up in it. It's capital intensive. The lifetime of this infrastructure is long. So, the path to net zero is going to take thirty or more years.

My hope is that fifteen years from now, we look back and there is work happening that seems challenging when we think about it today, but by then, we've figured it out.