Law & Lawyers

Cost of Electricity in the Roaring 20s: Minneapolis

Lighting a lamp in Minneapolis was a pricey proposition.

Yesterday we looked at the cost of electricity in Wichita, Kansas in 1923. Today we'll look at the cost of electricity in Minneapolis in 1926, ninety years ago. 

Minneapolis General Electric charged ten cents per kilowatt-hour for the first three kilowatt-hours used over the course of a month, per room. Per room?

So the number of rooms in your home impacted your electric rate and bill. Because the utility charged seven and a half cents per kilowatt-hour for the next three kilowatt-hours. Again, per room.

Before Electric Industry Consolidation

In New York City, as many as ten privately-owned utilities provided service.

The lead article in the June issue of Public Utilities Fortnightly, by Tom Flaherty and Owen Ward, tells the story of the electric industry's consolidation. The impact on the number and size of companies has been extraordinary.

Let's go back in time, to well before the consolidation of the last 20 years.

Take a look at the 1925 NELA Rate Book, published 91 years ago. NELA, the National Electric Light Association, was the Edison Electric Institute of its day.

Electricity Industry's First Convention

“Let us in a friendly way compare notes, tell each other all we know, tell each other anything that has been a benefit to us and can be to others.”

The annual convention of the Edison Electric Institute was held last week in Chicago, at the Sheraton Grand Hotel. The first annual convention of what was then called the National Electric Light Association was also held in Chicago, at the Grand Pacific Hotel. 

That was some time ago. The first convention was called to order at 11 a.m. on February 25, 1885. A conference in Chicago in February?

Thomas Edison's Pearl Street Station had started serving customers just two and a half years earlier. The electricity industry was very new.

Crossword Puzzle answers, July 2016

Spoiler alert! Here are answers to the crossword puzzle, State PUCs, in the July 2016 issue of Public Utilities Fortnightly:

Across

1. Typical no. of commissioners in states: five

3. Very common in commission names: service

5. In Iowa, New Jersey, Vermont's names: board

7. Commissions' association: naruc

9. Smaller no. of commissioners in states: three

11. Commissioners' research arm: nrri

12. ___ discrimination: undue

13. Acronym for commission: psc

19. Commissions' judges: alj

How Electric/Gas Utility Expenses Vary by Age

As households age, they spend less on electricity in dollars, but more as a percent of all their expenditures

The Labor Department has published Consumer Expenditure Survey data on how Americans of different ages spend differently. The survey shows how age affects expenses for electric and natural gas utility service. 

Twenty-two percent of households were classified as the youngest. Those surveyed averaged twenty-seven years old. 

These households spent $1,125 on electric service, on average, during the twelve months through June 2015. 

PPI for Generation Lowest Since 2004

Electric generation prices in August were at their lowest point since August 2004, twelve years ago

Electric generation prices are down 15.7 percent since 2011. Prices are down 19.7 percent since 2008.

October excerpt: Why financial strength matters

An excerpt from October’s Public Utilities Fortnightly, among the 23 articles, columns and letters in this issue

An excerpt from October’s Public Utilities Fortnightly, From the Editor, pages 4 and 6:

If you believe the nation’s electric grid (including its generating, transmission and distribution infrastructure) doesn’t need much tending to, doesn’t need much capital investment, then the financial strength of our utilities doesn’t matter much to you. 

But consider the converse. If you believe the grid does need much tending to, does need much investment, then the financial strength of our utilities does matter a whole lot to you… 

Flat Rates Were Known in 1917 as the American Plan 

A number of states are discussing retail electric and gas distribution rates based on demand considerations. It may come as a surprise, to some, that demand rates are not new at all to the public utility industry. 

According to my 1917 edition of Public Utility Rates by Harry Barker, the concept of a multi-part tariff was first introduced in 1892. 

Dr. John Hopkinson in England gave an address to the Junior Engineering Society. His two-part demand and energy rate is still known as the Hopkinson Demand Rate. 

'Cause We are the Champions of the World

With electric service at the all-time low as a share of consumer expenditures, it’s time for regulators, utilities, advocates to claim their achievement.

We are the champions.
We are the champions.
No time for losers.
'Cause we are the champions of the world.


As we wrote yesterday, electric service has never been cheaper for the American consumer than it was in November. Never. Ever. 

Over the last 695 months! Since January 1959, when The Chipmunk Song and then Smoke Gets in Your Eyes made it to the top of the Billboard Hot 100.